Are the Big Consultancies Now Stealing a March on Traditional Agency Business?


innovation-wording

 

 

 

The Yahoo! acquisition of Tumblr has occupied the attention of every digital media blogger and wannabe trade journalist over the past few weeks. We were subjected to endless pieces on the reasons for the deal: Social. Mobile. Millennials. Native. Porn. The list goes on. $1.1 billion dollars is a lot of money – and those journos and professional observers, who will never truly understand the mechanics of this deal, ultimately demand satisfaction.

ExchangeWire is not here to second-guess the thinking of Marissa Mayer. She is a very capable lady, and there are so many reasons why she is the CEO of Yahoo! and none of the rest of us will ever be. We will say this briefly, that this could well be a massive opportunity for RightMedia to offer programmatic ‘content sponsorship’ (or native, bah) on both Yahoo! and Tumblr properties. A comeback is potentially in the cards.

The Tumblr deal aside, the other recent big M&A action has been the Accenture acquisition of Acquity. The deal was only for $330 million dollars (three times revenue) – a ridiculous multiple given the amount of money paid for Tumblr, which did $15 million dollars in revenue last year. VCs can argue whatever crazy economic model they want, but the price paid for Tumblr seems like lunacy. What was so significant about Accenture’s acquisition was that it bought an agency.

It is just another example of how consultancy firms are encroaching on traditional agency territory. As the enterprise marketing and ad tech worlds collide, Accenture sees massive opportunity in growing its digital marketing business – but why now? What has changed to make companies like McKinsey and Accenture move into traditional agency territory?

Data-Driven Planning: Automating Core Media Buying Functions

 

It might not be publicly admitted by Agency Trading Desks, but the process of media buying and planning is becoming automated. The rise of programmatic buying means that increasingly buyers/planners at the coal face are actually being divorced from the execution/optimisation process. Maybe this has always been thus, given that ad networks have been doing the heavy lifting on behalf of agencies over the last ten years.

With the introduction of programmatic buying, that ad net function has either been replaced by specialist agency units (ATDs, etc.) or even by – recently-pivoted – buying platforms like AudienceScience. Let us also not forget about the enterprise players making inroads into ad tech, such as Salesforce and Oracle. The $2.5 billion dropped on an email solution provider, Exact Targeting, shows how serious Salesforce is about owning the enterprise marketing stack.

Accenture has been looking on as this part of the media buying process has undergone significant technological evolution. If the process does become even more automated, is there a chance that Accenture could go to a Google, AppNexus, MediaOcean or Turn and outsource this buying/planning function. Buys informed by data and tech would allow Accenture to sidestep an increasingly low-margin business. This is what media planning/buying has become – increasingly a race to the bottom.

So, why would Accenture move into this business? Its recent deal with BMW suggests that Accenture wants to deepen its relationship with existing clients. Owning the entire relationship (including the ‘automated’ media buying process) would allow it to upsell high-margin business, like analytics and tech integrations. Acquity was an inroad into the e-commerce consultancy business – and really one of the big groups should have bought it.

Accenture: The New-Age Agency With Tech & Data at its Foundation

We, as an industry, have been throwing around terms like ‘big data’ and ‘data-driven’ for the past three years, as if we had made some massive leap forward. This could not be further from the truth. Traditional agencies have been actively trying to build this capability into its DNA, but it is not an easy task.

It takes many years for this transition to happen. Accenture is fundamentally a tech and data company. You cannot say this is the case for the likes WPP and Publicis. These groups are led by accountants and traditional agency men/women. The change required will need to be significant – a top down approach.

When some of the top-tier finally step down, maybe agencies will need to hire a CEO/COO who truly understands tech and data at its very core. If they are to successfully compete, they will need to hire someone from IBM, Google or McKinsey who can effect a cultural change within the organisations.

Continue reading on www.exchangewire.com



Categories: Digital Advertising, Leadership

Tags: ,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Gigaom

Technology news, trends and analysis covering mobile, big data, cloud, science, energy and media

The healthy rawr chic

You must be willing and determined to achieve a state of mind, body, and soul beyond what this world imagines could be possible. —Mayra Mejia BA MS

Brand Leadership Blog

The leading forum worldwide for executives and researchers addressing the challenges of building and sustaining great brands

INSIDEDIGITAL

Intelligence for Brand Marketers

Digital Buzz Blog

INTELLIGENCE FOR BRAND MARKETERS

ciaobasta

Startups, entrepreneurs, ideas. Let's make it informal

Brian Solis

INTELLIGENCE FOR BRAND MARKETERS

HubSpot Marketing Blog

INTELLIGENCE FOR BRAND MARKETERS

ReadWrite

INTELLIGENCE FOR BRAND MARKETERS

Marketing Pilgrim - Internet News and Opinion

INTELLIGENCE FOR BRAND MARKETERS

advergirl

INTELLIGENCE FOR BRAND MARKETERS

Posts from the Econsultancy blog

INTELLIGENCE FOR BRAND MARKETERS

Get Elastic Ecommerce Blog

INTELLIGENCE FOR BRAND MARKETERS

%d bloggers like this: